This article provides a case study on ms arthur anderson aa. Inside arthur andersen provides a perceptive analysis of the changes in cultural values that took andersen from the top of the accounting profession to its doom. In 2005, the supreme court of the us remitted the verdict against arthur andersen. The paper describes the political, historical, and economic conditions that led to enrons rise and fall from a variety of leadership and ethical perspectives. United states is a country where auditing and accounting principles are so strong. Business ethics decisionmaking cases writeups arthur andersen. Enrons fall 2001 collapse wound up taking down the accounting firm arthur andersen, too.
Accounting fraud at worldcom case solution and analysis. Case study on ms arthur anderson aa your article library. Arthur andersen llp andersen defendant was enrons accountant during enrons financial record manipulation scandal in 2002. The firm was indicted for having approved enrons books, and went out of business.
Overview arthur andersen is an accounting and consulting service that operates businesses throughout the world. Arthur andersen llp was founded in chicago in 19 by arthur andersen. Jean caragher, president of capstone marketing, which specializes in cpa firms, said that arthur andersen is an interesting case, because the damage to the brand in the wake of the enron scandal was so heavy. He responded to audience telephone calls, faxes, and. Arthur anderson was the accounting firm that was auditing enron for the year in which it falsified its financial statements to appear profitable in years that it was really taking losses. However, enron was not the firms first or only failure. The b case covers arthur andersens relationship with enron, one of the great success stories of the new economy boom.
Conflicts existed within spinoffs such as the case with epp, a publicallyheld spin off that would purchase assets from enron so the company could book the sale of those assets as profits. This paper provides an overview of the rise and fall of the american energy company enron. Ethical questions categorical imperative respect for public interest arthur anderson charges reversed in 2005 2001 united states federal law which set new standards for all u. The enron accounting scandal is one of the most shocking nightmares in the professions history. To provide a rendering of the rise and fall of the enron organization. Enron management hid substantial financial losses, leading to the collapse of. Enron case study history, ethics and governance failures. The enron accounting scandal as 2002 began, energy trader enron corp. The enron scandal is a case study of the ethical dilemmas that huge companies face in regard to observing moral rights or wrongs and the desire to report impressive financial results to investors. In light of arthur andersens role in the enron debacle, it is important to note that, no matter what the facts, arthur andersen had an obligation to look out for the public interest, to protect the integrity of the freemarket system duska, 70. Enron rises to success quickly after its establishment in 1985. The level of complexity of the fraud found in worldcom were more of judgement as opposed to those complex issues raised through enron who arthur anderson also. By 2001, it had become one of the worlds largest multinational businesses.
To precise the opinion, the auditors shouldmeasure the register of the business, examine its assets and transactions. When the securities and exchange commission opened an informal investigation of enron, andersen began telling its employees as well as enron employees to strictly adhere to the companys document retention policy, meaning that if any enron. The enron scandal in early 2001 forever changed the face of business. This may be the most important analysis coming out of the corporate. The case also examines the criminal charges faced by the firm in the enron. Supreme court has overturned the obstruction of justice conviction of enron accounting firm arthur andersen, ruling unanimously today that a houston jury received flawed instructions from. Arthur andersen llp was an american holding company based in chicago. The fallout of arthur andersen and enron on the legal landscape. This book provides a thoughtprovoking account of how the firms culture. Nevertheless, the discharge did not help one of the worlds leading auditing companies to.
She noted, however, that there were a number of factors at play that kept it from being forever tarnished. In the case of enron, however, arthur andersen failed at their duties. Fall of arthur andersenbusiness ethicscase studycase studies. Arthur andersen collapse in 2002, the investigation was finished and aa was found guilty. Arthur andersen is an accounting firm that was founded in 19 and based in chicago, illinois.
The independence of the auditor and the execution of prudent accounting and regulatory laws are vital in preventing scandals of this nature in future. However, in some cases, the method can be manipulated, since mtm is. Arthur andersen enron scandal case custom elite writers. Enron summery of enron case the enron scandal has farreaching political and financial implications. The auditor of enron, arthur andersen, also admits that his employees destroyed confidential documents related to enron as a result of the public scandal that was generated by the fraud. The new consulting company promptly changed its name to. The scandal also affected the greater business world by causing the dissolution of the arthur andersen accounting firm, which had been enrons main auditor for years. While the arthur andersenenron scandal is probably the most memorable of. Daniels fund ethics initiative university of new mexico. Now that act has led to the first indictment in a case that is much bigger than andersen, a case that shined a harsh light on the accounting. Enron was hardly the first corporate scandal in which arthur andersen was implicated. With your download, get the 17 best papers relevant to this one, including 14 top related papers. The incident of arthur andersen serves as an example for other accounting firms.
Arthur andersen, established in 19 became one of the most coveted and prestigious accounting firms in the world and a part of the big five. While arthur andersen was not implicated in directly assisting enron in cooking its books, the company was found to have been woefully negligent. Through its subsidiaries and numerous affiliates, the company provided products and services related to natural gas, electricity, and communications for its wholesale and retail customer. In less than a year, enron had gone from being considered one of the most innovative companies of the late 20th century to being deemed a byword for corruption and mismanagement. Ais 3202 submitted to abdul alim baser lecturer, department of ais university of barisal submitted by tusher ghosh on behalf of group 05 12. The major players in financial fraud were worldcom chief financial officer scott sullivan, general accounting and internal audit, the external auditor arthur andersen, and the board of directors. The research paper on capstone case study arthur andersen llp. The doomed accounting firm of arthur andersen emerges as a grownup version. The paper also analyzes the impact of policy responses to.
In addition, the authors display great insight into what made andersen great and the changes that led it to fail, while also raising serious questions about the remaining. How to cite informative essay on enron case study, case study choose cite format. Arthur andersen, as a whole, employed more than 85,000 people worldwide. Greising discussed the arthur andersen accounting corporation and the enron bankruptcy. Enron case study the case of enron is a fascinating one. Its audit firm, arthur andersen, continued to peform internal audit and consulting services while also providing an external audit, in effect, auditing itself. Arthur andersens conviction on obstruction of justice charges related to the enron debacle. Naturally, no one stepped forward to shoulder the blame for worldcoms accounting scandal, not its auditors, executives, board of directors, or analysts. Summary of the case case 2 mainly introduces how arthur andersen, who used to be one of the big five largest accounting firms in the united states, strayed away from accepted policies. As for the differences, adelphia did not have an independent internal auditor. Arthur andersens role in the enron scandal due to the sometimes complex nature of financial matters, many may not be familiar with.
Enrons history the enron corporation was created out of the merger of two major gas pipeline companies in 1985. Please place the order on the website to order your own originally done case solution. Andersen advised enron that it would employ an agreeable method of accounting to justify the unbalanced books. Case study arthur andersen in the collapse of enron. Supreme court overturns arthur andersens enron conviction. Summary of the case case 2 mainly introduces how arthur andersen, who used to be one of the big five largest accounting firms in the united states, strayed away from accepted policies and stuck in a string. By 1992, enron was the largest selling company of natural gas in north america. Andersen, an accounting professor at northwestern university, formed a partnership with clarence m. The arthur andersenenron case came to light when enron suffered a collapse in. The founder, arthur andersen, was born in 1885 in a small town in illinois. Three of the five largest bankruptcies ever recorded were those of andersen clients with accounting problems london, s. The case of enron and worldcom 1490 words bartleby. Inside arthur andersen provides a perceptive analysis of the changes in cultural.
It is the first in a new series assessing organisations against acgs golden rules of corporate governance and applying our proprietary rating tool as we say in our business ethics examples homepage introducing this series, the first and most critical rule is an ethical approach, and this should. Arthur andersen ethical conflict case study solution. Agenda ooverview othe advent of anderson consulting oenron scandal ocorporate culture and ethical ramifications ocase analysis oconclusion 2. Both adelphia scandal and worldcom scandal were not prevented by companys external auditor, though deloitte and touche and arthur andersen both rated their client as high risk. The new consulting company promptly changed its name to accenture the following january. Download arthur andersen case daniels fund ethics initiative. This enron case study presents our own analysis of the spectacular rise and fall of enron.
Adelphia scandal and worldcom scandal essay studymoose. Arthur andersens involvement being the auditors of worldcom would have been to find the irregularities in the companys accounts. The result is a case study ingroup dependency, in which moral chaos. The case study of enron, sample of research papers. Arthur andersen, in turn, issued unqualified opinions in the audit report for waste management, inc. Enron scandal, series of events that resulted in the bankruptcy of the u. In addition to being the largest bankruptcy reorganization in american history at that. It examines andersens role in accounting fraud at enron, one of its major clients. As the primary outside auditor, arthur andersen also under fire for alleged mismanagement of many other large scandalplagued audits. After that trial, all public trust vanished along with their clients. The partners split in 1918 and the firm became arthur andersen.
Investing essentials fundamental analysis portfolio management trading. Once the two companies andersen consulting and arthur anderson split, arthur andersen, which was originally the auditing only. However, the trial case established that the partners and employees of andersen personally led the efforts to destroy the evidence. When enrons aggressive use of offbalance sheet partnerships became impossible to hide in autumn 2001, news reports stated that andersen auditors had engaged in extensive shredding of draft documents and associated. Arthur andersen accounting firm dismisses david b duncan, partner in charge of. Arthur andersen and enron in addition to andrew fastow, a major player in the enron scandal was enrons accounting firm arthur andersen llp and partner david b. The wave of corporate financial scandals has served to emphasize the. In october 2001 a scandal involving enron was emerging. The enron scandal, revealed in october 2001, eventually led to the bankruptcy of the enron corporation, anamerican energy company based in houston, texas. How the arthur anderson and enron fraud changed accounting. Participating by remote connection from chicago, mr. Despite this success, arthur anderson was also a part of one of the largest fraud scandals in history.
1055 1402 1634 1005 325 814 766 587 953 1134 1295 1293 1468 1383 1512 884 1364 1179 1364 1130 17 219 1583 1003 1193 949 928 1479 1215 835 1122 406 18 954 601 627 50 303 1010 275